Ring of Fire News


What's up with the biggest thing happening in mining in NW Ontario?

Ring of Fire News – July 23, 2014

  • Premier, yesterday during Question Period, on the $1B question  “We have committed to setting up a development corporation that would include all of the parties, and we very much hope that the federal government is at the table, because in order for that infrastructure to be completely developed and in order for those chromite and mineral deposits to be realized, we need everyone working together. We have committed $1 billion. We are firm in that commitment. We will work to set up a development corporation …. we are going ahead. We are working to set up the development corporation, because we believe that this is an opportunity that will benefit not just the region, not just the province, but the country.”
  • Toronto transportation consultant raises good question  “Trains or trucks? That is the burning question that must be answered in the debate over the Ring of Fire’s transportation options. In a bygone era, the overwhelming choice would have been rail. As generations of Canadian school children once learned, it was the railways that opened up Northern Ontario and most of the country, economically and socially. Even in the subsequent era when rail lost its monopoly, trains remained the winners when it came to providing access to large, long-term resource developments. The construction of the CP and CN branch lines to Manitouwadge’s copper mines in the 1950s is a prime example. But trains haven’t fared well in these competitions in Canada in recent years, even as they are growing in importance in other developed and developing nations. Consequently, many rail proponents regard the Ring of Fire’s modal choice a litmus test for the direction of transportation policy, federally and provincially. Will rail solutions once again be part of the Canadian planning and decision-making processes? ….”
  • Green Party on the Ring of Fire  “A motion calling for responsible development of the Ring of Fire, passed at the Green Party of Canada’s biennial meeting in Fredericton, puts “the party in the game” and shows it has good ideas other parties might want to consider. Sudbury’s Steve May attended the convention and was surprised to learn every person attending had heard about the rich chromite deposits 540 kilometres northeast of Thunder Bay — whether they were from British Columbia or New Brunswick. May has been thinking of the Ring of Fire as a regional issue, “but had I lived in Alberta in the early ’80s, I might have thought the development of the tar sands was a regional issue. “We know it’s not,” he said of the Ring of Fire. “It’s a national project.” Before delegates to the convention met, they agreed to put a motion on the weekend agenda calling for a five-pillar policy to develop the area. It addresses community benefits, energy, transportation, value-added industry and lifecycle planning for extracted resources. To maximize the Ring of Fire’s economic potential for Canada, the Greens’ policy is calling for the creation of a working group to assess the feasibility of a value-added stainless steel industry as a requirement of development ….”Green Party news release on convention (no apparent links to resolutions passed)
  • More on Aboriginals training to be ready for Ring of Fire jobs  “Better career options are the goal for many of the Matawa First Nations trainees currently pursuing Ring of Fire Training Alliance (RoFATA) Tier 2 and 3 training. “(My goal is) to eventually get a really good career where I can support my family and move out of Thunder Bay into a different community,” said Caitlin Cheechoo, mother of a three-year-old son and one of about 60 Tier 3 RoFATA trainees who have completed about three weeks of their 12-week program at Confederation College in Thunder Bay. “Right now, all together, we’re learning the math and English components and then we branch out to our own individual (pre-trades program).” Cheechoo is focusing on the Pre-Trades Carpentry program, one of five programs offered through the Tier 3 RoFATA training. The other programs are: Pre-Trades Electrical, Pre-Trades Plumber, Pre-Trades Heavy Duty Equipment Mechanic and Pre-Trades Construction Craft Worker. “I just like the hands-on working with everything,” Cheechoo said ….”
  • Documentary film maker eyes Ring of Fire  “Lalita Krishna has no intention of following the same contrived script that’s evident in the mining reality shows currently being embraced by network television. The award-winning Toronto producer of television documentaries intends to drill down to the essence of the multi-faceted world of mining by documenting the lives of the people who toil at the grassroots edge of the industry. Krishna recalls spending four bone-chilling days with Barb Courte Elinesky, CEO of two Thunder Bay drilling companies, and her rugged crew shooting video in a remote exploration site in Greenstone last March. The conditions were harsh, a vehicle became stuck on an access road, and they returned to their hotel in Beardmore one night after an exhausting day to find all the restaurants closed. “When I was with Barb in that extreme environment; the drama happens naturally, you don’t have to create those situations or stage anything.” The mining industry is new subject matter for the Indian-born Krishna, who worked as a producer at TV Ontario before venturing out on her own as an independent documentary producer ….”
  • KWG Resources Inc. announces that it will not reconvene its Annual and General Meeting of Shareholders on July 30, 2014 at 11:00 am (local time) at the offices of Norton Rose Fulbright Canada LLP, Suite 3800, Royal Bank Plaza, South Tower, 200 Bay Street, Toronto, Ontario. The special resolutions to amend the Company’s articles to include the authority to issue preference shares and to let all shareholders wishing to do so acquire with each fifty of their present shares one new multiple-voting share (provided that these may be converted back into the fifty subordinate voting shares at any subsequent time of their choosing) have been withdrawn. “While there is substantial support for both initiatives, some of our largest shareholders feel that they would prefer to have an opportunity to subsequently approve the specifics of any proposed preferred share issue when terms have been negotiated,” explained KWG President Frank Smeenk ….”


Filed under: Uncategorized

Questions about RoF Development Corp?

  • May 25, 2014, CBC.ca:  “…. Wynne …. re-launched the creation of the Ring of Fire development corporation. The corporation had been previously announced, but the Liberals now say they will create the consortium within 60 days of being elected ….”
  • July 3, 2014, “Speech from the Throne to open the 41st Parliament of Ontario” “…. Within the next 60 days, your government will establish a Ring of Fire development corporation and move forward in a smart, sustainable and collaborative way with First Nations, the private sector and communities to unlock the enormous mineral potential in Northern Ontario ….”
  • July 16, 2014, Sudbury Star “Significant work is being done to establish a Ring of Fire development corporation and keep a campaign promise that it be done within 60 days of a Liberal government being elected.  But it’s not clear when the clock began ticking on that 60-day guarantee, says Michael Gravelle, who was reappointed Northern Development and Mines minister by Premier Kathleen Wynne.  Nor is it clear what exactly is meant by “establishing” the development corporation.  Gravelle doesn’t know if the 60 days started when he was sworn in June 24 or when his government delivered its Throne Speech on July 3.  And he and his staff are working to determine what exactly will be in put place during the 60-day commitment.  “We are not there yet in terms of determining exactly what form it will take other than that we are grateful to have the opportunity to move this project forward and to have this kind of a timeline in place,” said Gravelle in a telephone interview Tuesday from Queen’s Park ….”

If you believe the campaign speech, the deadline is August 11th.

If you believe the Speech from the Throne, the deadline is September 1.

The clock is ticking – pick your time to set the alarm.

Filed under: Uncategorized

Ontario Budget Backpedalling on Ring of Fire?

  • May 25, 2014, Kathleen Wynne speaking in Thunder Bay:  “…. we will commit a billion dollars, with or without the federal government involvement, towards the transportation infrastructure that will help make the Ring of Fire a reality”
  • July 14, 2014, Budget 2014(b) speech:  “Mr. Speaker, we will invest $1 billion in transportation infrastructure for the development of the Ring of Fire in Northern Ontario.”
  • July 14, 2014, page 63, Budget 2014(b) document (400+ page PDF):  “Planning to invest over $130 billion in public infrastructure over the next 10 years, including …. Committing up to $1 billion towards  infrastructure development for the Ring of Fire contingent on matching investment by the federal government.
  • July 14, 2014, page 89, Budget 2014(b) document:  “The Province is willing to commit up to $1 billion towards infrastructure development, contingent on matching investment by the federal government.”

Hmmmm …..

Filed under: Uncategorized

Ring of Fire News – July 11, 2014

  • Supreme Court of Canada decision: Ontario CAN issue logging permits, BUT ….  “…. The central question on this appeal is whether Ontario has the power to take up lands in the Keewatin area under Treaty 3 so as to limit the harvesting rights under the treaty, or whether this is subject to Canada’s approval. Ontario and only Ontario has the power to take up lands under Treaty 3. This is confirmed by constitutional provisions, the interpretation of the treaty, and legislation dealing with Treaty 3 lands …. Ontario’s power to take up lands under Treaty 3 is not unconditional. When a government — be it the federal or a provincial government — exercises Crown power, the exercise of that power is burdened by the Crown obligations toward the Aboriginal people in question. Here, Ontario must exercise its powers in conformity with the honour of the Crown, and the exercise of those powers is subject to the fiduciary duties that lie on the Crown in dealing with Aboriginal interests. For Treaty 3 land to be taken up, the harvesting rights of the Ojibway over the land must be respected. Any taking up of land in the Keewatin area for forestry or other purposes must meet the conditions set out by this Court in Mikisew Cree First Nation v. Canada (Minister of Canadian Heritage), [2005] 3 S.C.R. 388, 2005 SCC 69. If the taking up leaves the Ojibway with no meaningful right to hunt, fish or trap in relation to the territories over which they traditionally hunted, fished, and trapped, a potential action for treaty infringement will arise ….” – The Canadian PressCBC.caReutersFinancial Post - Netnewsledger.comQMI/Sun MediaAPTNmore via Google News
  • Fraser Institute report: Recent Supreme Court decision = more uncertainty for business in B.C.?  “…. The judgment reaffirms that consultation processes and the justification of infringements of Aboriginal rights and title are the responsibility of the Crown and not project proponents. It will mean that if development is to occur on Aboriginal title land against the wishes of the First Nation, governments will have to be advocates for third party projects. Where there is no consent, and the potential infringement cannot be justified, proposed projects may be set aside by the court. This is also true for existing development projects. This puts current and potential development at risk and results in increased uncertainty for economic development in British Columbia ….”  Fraser Institute news release – media coverage (Google News)
  • Ontario’s response to the Tsilhqot’in Supreme Court decision includes Ring of Fire mention  “…. The Tsilhqot’in Nation decision builds on earlier decisions of the Supreme Court, including the Delgamuukw, Haida and Mikisew cases, that have given meaning to the constitutional protection of aboriginal and treaty rights and established principles that guide governments in their relationships with aboriginal communities …. It’s also in the spirit of these earlier rulings that, this year, the government signed a historic regional framework agreement with the nine Matawa member First Nations for negotiations on sustainably developing the Ring of Fire. It’s one of the most significant mineral regions in the province, with mineral potential known to be worth $60-billion, including the largest deposit of chromite ever discovered in North America. This government-to-government relationship ensures that these First Nations participate in, and benefit from, proposed development in the Ring of Fire. We’ve also announced the creation of a development corporation that aims to bring together key mining companies, First Nations, and the provincial and federal governments to develop infrastructure in the Ring of Fire region ….”
  • From the KWG Info-machine  “Toronto stockbroker Pope & Company announced …. that it has initiated research coverage on KWG Resources Inc. Well-known mining analyst Jay Turner recommends the shares of KWG as a speculative buy with a target price of $0.20. “Jay has done an outstanding job of researching, interpreting and understanding our published views of the opportunities for the creation of an enterprise following from the discoveries in the Ring of Fire”, said KWG President Frank Smeenk. “We are very gratified with both the coverage and the recommendation, which is quite unusual for a junior exploration company. We appreciate the confidence!” ….”
  • More from the KWG Info-machine  “KWG Resources Inc. retracts from its press release issued this morning …. The earlier release advised that Toronto stockbroker Pope & Company announced this morning that it has initiated research coverage on KWG. A Market Surveillance Officer of the Investment Industry Regulatory Organization of Canada (“IIROC”) required that the noted recommendation contained in the initial report be retracted as this is considered not to be balanced disclosure on the part of the Company ….” 
  • MOAR pessimism about Cliffs  “Cliffs Natural Resources’ battle with Casablanca Capital continues. The troubled miner has offered a settlement to the activist investor one more time. According to a Cliffs Natural Resources press release, the company has offered three seats on the Cliffs Board to Casablanca. What’s more, the board would be cut to nine members from current eleven if Casablanca accepted the proposal. Casablanca’s response was fast, and the activist investor rejected the offer. In my previous article on this story, I argued that both Casablanca’s and Cliffs Natural Resources’ plans were dubious. However, there seems to be another trap on the way for Cliffs Natural Resources, and that’s indecision ….”


Filed under: Uncategorized

Ring of Fire News – July 4, 2014

  • First off, happy 4th of July to American readers!
  • Ontario’s Speech from the Throne mentions Ring of Fire  “…. Within the next 60 days**, your government will establish a Ring of Fire development corporation and move forward in a smart, sustainable and collaborative way with First Nations, the private sector and communities to unlock the enormous mineral potential in Northern Ontario. Your government commits $1 billion for transportation infrastructure to help access the Ring of Fire.  Your government will continue its efforts to bring the federal government to the table as a willing and active partner, and will seek a matching federal commitment to seize the opportunity for Ontario and Canada that lies in the Ring of Fire ….”more 
  • ** – that means no later than 1 Sept 2014
  • Ontario Premier names new Secretary of the Cabinet (Ontario’s top civil servant)  “Ontario Premier Kathleen Wynne has named Steve Orsini as Secretary of the Cabinet and Clerk of the Executive Council. He will lead the Ontario Public Service effective July 9, 2014 ….”Orsini bio
  • More on that Supreme Court decision on Aboriginal title on land, from Noront  “The Supreme Court of Canada recently granted a declaration of Aboriginal title over a tract of Crown lands to the Tsilhqot’in Nation of the west central interior of British Columbia. This is the first time in Canadian history that Aboriginal title has been definitely established and affirmed.  Noront President & CEO Alan Coutts commented as follows:  “Noront Resources has involved local First Nations communities in the development of its Eagle’s Nest mine project from the very start incorporating several of their concerns into the very design of the mine. It has always been our intention to develop Eagle’s Nest in collaboration with the local communities as a true partnership. We don’t see the recent Supreme Court decision regarding native title in B.C. as a negative impact on development in the Ring of Fire; rather, it validates the approach we have taken over the last five years.” ….”
  • Lots more legal analysis of Tsilhqot’in Nation v. British Columbia also available over at lexology.com
  • The Annual Meeting of the shareholders of KWG Resources Inc. was convened Monday morning and elected Cynthia Thomas, Douglas Flett, Thomas Pladsen, Donald Sheldon and Frank Smeenk as directors. The shareholders also appointed McGovern, Hurley, Cunningham LLP, Chartered Accountants, as the auditors of the Company. Frank Smeenk, Thomas Masters and Luce St. Pierre were then respectively re-appointed as the Company’s President, Chief Financial Officer and Secretary and Douglas Flett was elected Chairman of the Board …. The meeting was adjourned to July 30, 2014 to then consider the special resolutions to amend the Company’s articles to include the authority to issue preferred shares and to let all shareholders wishing to do so acquire with each fifty of their present shares one new multiple-voting share (provided that these may be converted back into the fifty subordinate voting shares at any subsequent time of their choosing) ….”KWG news release
  • Northern mayors on the Ring o’ Fire  “Northern Ontario cities and towns need to speak as a single voice to be effective in getting the province to pay attention to the priorities of the region, said mayors meeting in North Bay Thursday.  While Northern Ontario accounts for 88% of the province’s area, it only has 6% of the population, and that can mean problems getting its voice heard.  “We realize to be successful we have to stick together,” explained North Bay Mayor Al McDonald. “And that’s what these meeting are all about, to reconfirm what is important to Northern Ontario and how we create jobs and bring wealth to our part of the province.”  McDonald says the group concentrated on issues such as economic development, energy costs, the ONTC and Ring of Fire …. McDonald says their next move is to put all their thoughts on paper, and request meetings with eight ministers at the Association of Municipalities of Ontario meeting in London next month.”
  • Ontario small business trying to twist Ottawa’s arm  “….  The Ontario Chamber of Commerce (OCC) along with seven other chambers across the province, including Thunder Bay, have written a letter to Minister of Natural Resources and FedNor Greg Rickford, who also represents the Kenora riding as a Member of Parliament.   The letter is asking for the federal government to match the province’s commitment of $1 billion in funding for infrastructure in the Ring of Fire ….”OCC news release
  • Have a great weekend! 


Filed under: Uncategorized

Ring of Fire News – June 29, 2014

  • (Somewhat) New Ontario CabinetGravelle still NorDev Minister, Thunder Bay-Atikokan MPP Bill Mauro new Minister of Natural Resources – check out the Parliamentary Assistants list here
  • “(Nipissing Tory MPP Vic) Fedeli seeks to meet new ministers”
  • Supreme Court of Canada (SCOC) rulingNative groups across Canada hailed as a “game-changer” the Supreme Court of Canada’s landmark decision to grant aboriginal title to a B.C. native group over a large tract of land — the first award of its kind …. Despite the euphoria, however, others say the 8-0 ruling does not bar economic development.  The ruling said provincial and federal governments may still regulate economic activity like forestry practices on aboriginal title lands as long as legislators win consent of the affected group, or can show “a pressing and substantial” public purpose for activity that must also be compatible with the Crown’s obligation to act in good faith for the benefit of aboriginal peoples ….” - more from media here
  • Chiefs of Ontario on SCOC ruling:  “Ontario Regional Chief Stan Beardy congratulates the Tsilhqot’in Nation today on being granted a historic declaration of Aboriginal title in a long-fought court case. It expands on the interpretation and application of the law in a way that promotes reconciliation holding up First Nations’ interests with respect to title. Most importantly, consent of the Aboriginal title holders will be required before any development moves forward.  “This precedent will have implications for major projects being planned in Ontario like the Ring of Fire, Energy East and Line 9B,” Regional Chief Stan Beardy said. “The case is important for clearer relations between First Nations, private business and the government and will further provide opportunity for First Nations to participate in the global economy. We are optimistic that this will have a positive impact on the Keewatin case in Ontario which is now before the Supreme Court of Canada.” ….”
  • Nishnawbe Aski Nation on SCOC ruling (PDF):  “This unanimous decision by the Supreme Court sends a very strong message that the Crown, as represented by the Government of Canada, must recognize and respect Aboriginal title and deal honourably with First Nations.  The written ruling by Chief Justice McLachlin takes a broad view of Aboriginal title and supports the ownership of lands that have been occupied and used for centuries by First Nations. This has widespread implications and provides useful guidance for all NAN First Nations engaged in land claims and various stages of economic and resource development projects.  We expect that the principles laid out by this decision will have a significant impact on resource development in Nishnawbe Aski, including the Ring of Fire, as it supports First Nation rights to control development in our traditional territories.”
  • One mining analyst‘s view  “A landmark Supreme Court of Canada ruling recognizing a First Nation’s title to a large tract of land in the B.C. interior doesn’t hold much relevance to any future development in Ontario’s North, especially the Ring of Fire, said a strategist, lawyer, and author on Native involvement in the resource sector.  This “seismic event” on the West Coast that granted the Tsilhqot’in Nation formal title to 1,700-square-kilometres of its traditional territory, said Bill Gallagher, likely won’t apply in Ontario since the issue of title was already settled when the numbered treaties were signed ….”
  • Questions from a First Nation minerals analyst/activist about government’s ulterior motives behind seeing training and other benefits flow to First Nations from the Ring of Fire “…. On the surface, these strategies seem progressive in the sense that they are focused on the redistribution of wealth though revenue sharing, but they are really a containment strategy akin to the transition from wildcat strikes to national labour legislation in the 1930s.  Just as the the right to strike was contained within the right to labour peace in collective bargaining, the demands of First Nation for sovereignty, and all the land rights and decision-making power that go with sovereignty, have been contained in the new social contract.  The enlightened Canadian elites, fearing indigenous resistance — most famously represented in the Idle No More movement — are creating a First Nation social contract reform agenda that includes resource revenue sharing, project equity and an elaborate consultation process.  It is all designed to blunt the more radical demands of indigenous sovereignty movements for real decision-making and control of natural resources on their lands ….”
  • One lawyer‘s overview of the duty to consult in mining projects
  • “Better career options are the goal for many of the Matawa First Nations trainees currently pursuing Ring of Fire Training Alliance (RoFATA) Tier 2 and 3 training.  “(My goal is) to eventually get a really good career where I can support my family and move out of Thunder Bay into a different community,” said Caitlin Cheechoo, mother of a three-year-old son and one of about 60 Tier 3 RoFATA trainees who have completed about three weeks of their 12-week program at Confederation College in Thunder Bay ….”
  • Some federal money going into chambers of commerce studying mining opportunities  “The Honourable Greg Rickford, Canada’s Minister of Natural Resources and Minister for the Federal Economic Development Initiative for Northern Ontario (FedNor), announced today an investment to assist the Northwestern Ontario Associated Chambers of Commerce (NOACC) explore options for maximizing the potential of Northwestern Ontario’s mining supply and services companies.  The Harper Government investment is helping NOACC in reviewing and analysing successful business models from across Canada that could be used to further develop and grow the region’s mining supply and service sector, as well as assessing the financial viability of a regional association …. The Harper Government investment of $22,500 …. is provided through FedNor’s Northern Ontario Development Program, which supports projects that promote sustainable community economic development, enhance business development and growth, and facilitate innovation throughout the region.”
  • “In an Order dated June 24, 2014 the Provincial Mining Recorder for Ontario has confirmed that KWG Resources Inc. was the first to stake two 16-unit claim blocks after they came open on the morning of June 17, 2011. The two claim blocks are contiguous to the southern two claim blocks of the Fancamp Exploration Ltd. Koper Lake claims where KWG is assessing the economic potential of the Black Horse chromite deposit under an option agreement with Bold Ventures Inc. and Fancamp. The Mining Recorder’s Order provides that KWG will have until June 24, 2016 to perform and file the first unit of assessment work ….”
  • Pre-election, but some questions in the alternative media about what the province should be thinking about in the Ring of Fire  “…. What are the likely benefits of a $1-billion investment in a transportation corridor to the Ring of Fire compared to other equivalent investments in northern Ontario? …. What infrastructure? What route and to service what projects? …. How will mining infrastructure benefit First Nations? …. What are the companies willing to invest for infrastructure and what conditions will the government put on its financial investment? ….”


Filed under: Uncategorized

Ring of Fire News – June 19, 2014

  • New Ring of Fire (RoF) study (1) This, from a regional think tank ” Northern Policy Institute released a report …. that provides timely recommendations for government and industry on proposed infrastructure development in the Ring of Fire. According to the report authored by former Deputy Minister of Transport Canada, Nick Mulder, an Authority model similar to the Airport/Port Transportation Authority model would be a more effective model in the Ring of Fire infrastructure development than a traditional Crown Corporation model.   Currently, there are major challenges facing mineral development in a remote area of Northern Ontario known as the Ring of Fire including who will pay for the required infrastructure and how it will be organized, planned, managed and implemented. In the Airport/Port Transportation Authority model proposed by Mulder, the onus and risks would be placed on all stakeholders and not just on the provincial government and taxpayers. Says Mulder, “Under a Crown Corporation model, the responsibility would be on the shoulders of the Province. The provincial government would be expected to review and approve plans on all major projects, fund the largest portion s of the costs and accept most of the risks. Simply put, the buck would stop at Queen’s Park” ….” - moremore
  • KWG Resources: We like the Institute’s idea! “KWG Resources Inc. applauds the release …. by the Northern Policy Institute of its Commentary No. 1 | Friday, June 13, 2014, The Airport/Port Transportation Authority Model, Is It Applicable for Ontario’s Ring of Fire Mineral Development? authored by Nick Mulder. “The Northland Development Corporation Bill that we proposed to all candidates who recently sought election to the Ontario Legislature, is fashioned after the governance model of a Port/Airport Authority”, said KWG President Frank Smeenk. “We originally concluded that the federal government might be the better sponsor of such a corporation, because the Ontario government had then declared its intention to dispose of the assets of the Ontario Northland Transportation Commission. These are legacy assets that can assist the Ring of Fire deposits to achieve very long-term economic viability in a highly competitive global market for stainless steel inputs. If our Bill is adopted by Ontario’s newly-elected parliament, it would effectively create a provincial Transportation Authority on the model of the many such very successful federal agencies across Canada. However, the Bill can as easily become the charter of a federally incorporated Transportation Authority and so benefit from the sponsorship of the governments of both Canada and Ontario. As both governments have pledged their support for development of the Ring of Fire, this might be a most elegant means for their collaboration.” ….”more
  • And speaking of KWG …. “KWG Annual And Special Meeting Of Shareholders To Convene June 30, 2014 — KWG Resources Inc. has postponed until June 30, 2014 the convening of its Annual and Special Meeting of Shareholders at 11:00 a.m. (local time) at Suite 3800, Royal Bank Plaza, South Tower, 200 Bay Street, Toronto, Ontario ….”
  • Some very pessimistic assessments of Cliffs  “The price of iron ore is collapsing. Unless it rapidly reverses its course, Cliffs Natural is not going to be around for long ….”moremore
  • New RoF study (2)  This, from environmental NGOs  “With the Ontario government poised to spend $1 billion to promote development in the Ring of Fire, a new paper from Wildlife Conservation Society (WCS) Canada and Ecojustice identifies risks inherent in the current planning legislation and provides a solution. Ontario’s Far North is the world’s largest ecologically intact area of boreal forest. It contains North America’s largest wetlands, is home to a number of at-risk species, including caribou and lake sturgeon, and is a one of the world’s critical storehouses of carbon. First Nations depend on these systems for food and medicines, sustenance of culture and spiritual values, their livelihoods, and rights. At the same time, the remote region contains potential world-class deposits of minerals that offer economic opportunities. Getting it Right in Ontario’s Far North: The Need for Strategic Environmental Assessment in the Ring of Fire (Wawangajing) points out that the current planning approaches in the Far North are piecemeal and narrowly focused on specific projects, or pieces of projects. Because of this, cumulative ecological and social effects, planning for regional infrastructure (roads, transmission lines, and railroads), and regional coordination, are not properly considered ….”more
  • A bit of pre-environmental-NGO-report academic commentary  “…. What is clearly needed is a regional-scale examination of how to encourage and guide Ring of Fire development so that it delivers multiple, lasting and fairly distributed net benefits. Such an initiative must respect the rights and interests of the First Nations affected by Ring of Fire development. It needs everyone at the table — federal, provincial and aboriginal governments, proponents and other stakeholders. And it can work only if the process is transparent enough to be credible, and only if the agenda goes beyond immediate issues to aim for desirable results 100 years from now ….”
  • Waiting to see the fall-out from the Ontario election ….  “The future of the Ring of Fire is in the air until the Ontario government returns to the legislature on July 2. “We’re all waiting to hear what the cabinet may be,” said John Mason, project manager of mining services for the Community Economic Development Commission, on Wednesday, Day 1 of the two-day Ontario Mining Forum being held at the Valhalla Inn ….”
  • …. with not long to wait  “Premier Kathleen Wynne and her cabinet will be sworn in to office at Queen’s Park on Tuesday, June 24, 2014 ….”
  • Post-election editorial  “…. Federal Natural Resources Minister Greg Rickford and his Ontario counterpart, Michael Gravelle, have been cautiously talking about how their governments will jointly encourage the development. Ontario had been urging Ottawa to commit equally to funding a transportation corridor to get supplies in and ore out. But when Rickford said Ontario could apply for Building Canada funds just the same as anyone else, Wynne turned it into a campaign promise to spend $1 billion unilaterally while criticizing Ottawa for not acting as decisively. There is some urgency to all of this. New U.S. carbon emission reduction targets will push up demand for the very minerals found in the Ring of Fire to produce the required technological innovations, along with the chromite it can supply for North American stainless steel. Once Ottawa gets on board the demand will be even higher. On this front especially, Ottawa and Ontario need to get along.”
  • (Not strictly RoF, but) Competing land rights issues not just being hashed out in Canadian courts  “In March 2014, an Australian court ruled that the Ngarla Peoples’ native title cannot be extinguished by preexisting mining leases. In 2007, the Ngarla Peoples secured native title to lands in the Pilbara region of Western Australia. The lands overlapped with a mining concession, awarded in 1964 and currently being developed by subsidiaries of BHP Billiton Limited, Itochu Corporation, and Mitsui & Co. The court was asked to determine whether this was grounds for termination of the Ngarla Peoples’ native title, on the supposition that both sets of rights cannot be exercised simultaneously. The court decided that this was not grounds for termination, but maintained that native title can be temporarily suspended if it conflicts with the interests of mining leaseholders. Although the ruling prioritizes the rights of mining leaseholders over those of native title holders, it creates a legal basis for their coexistence, and highlights why companies should be foreword-thinking in their approaches to Indigenous community engagement ….”

Filed under: Uncategorized

Liberal Majority for Ontario

Here’s one place you can check the results in more detail.

Here’s where you can check to see what everyone promised on the Ring of Fire during the campaign.

You can check a bit of news here, here and here.

Hope you had a chance to vote – enjoy your weekend!


Filed under: Uncategorized

Ontario election coming up ….

…. so I’m going to hold off on a “news” update until next week to allow, in the words of my swear-hero Malcolm Tucker, “the affairs of state to settle”.

While you’re waiting to see how the election numbers unfold, here’s a little summary (PDF via Google Drive) I’ve pulled together of what the main parties have been saying about the Ring of Fire.

Enjoy – and get out there and vote!

P.S. – For some reason, most of the Ontario Conservative party policy papers that were available last month on this page don’t seem to be available right now.  It appears the site they use to share the PDF’s isn’t working – let’s see if that gets fixed if they win.

Filed under: Uncategorized

Ring of Fire News – June 6, 2014

Filed under: Uncategorized

Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Join 233 other followers


Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 233 other followers